Fastest Modified Model of Hardy Cross Method for Ventilation Network Analysis of Mines (Second Conflation Model)

Document Type : Research Paper


Faculty of Mining, Petroleum and Geophysics Engineering, Shahrood University of Technology, Shahrood, Iran


Ventilation network design is done in manual and computerized methods. Computerized method is based on mathematical approximate methods. Several algorithms were presented in mathematical approximate methods for analyzing of water distribution and ventilation networks. Hardy Cross method is the most commonly model of mathematical approximate method for analyzing of ventilation networks in mine. For faster convergence to at the final result of Hardy Cross method were presented other models such as Wang model, conflation model and Newtonian models (First, third and sixteenth). In this paper is performed an initial review of Hardy Cross method and its modified models. Then first, third, and sixteenth modified models of Newtonian are presented for more accurate analysis of ventilation networks in mines. Finally, second conflation model will be presented as the fastest modified model of Hardy Cross method to achieve at the final result.


[1] Cross, H. (1936). Analysis of Flow in Networks of Conduits or Conductors. Bulletin 286, Engineering Experiment Station, University of Illinois, Urbane, 29 pp.
[2] Collins, M., Cooper, L., Helgason, R., Kennington, J., and LeBlanc, L. (1978). Solving the Pipe Network Analysis Problem Using Optimization Techniques. Management Science, Vol. 24, pp. 747-760.
[3] Chiplunkar, AV., Mehndiratta, SL., and Khanna, P. (1990). Analysis of looped water distribution networks. Environ Softw, 5(4): 202–6.
[4] Pramod R. Bhave. (1991). Analysis of Flow in Water Distribution Networks. Technomic Pub. Co. [5] Gupta, I., Bassin, JK., Gupta, A., and Khanna, P. (1993). Optimization of water distribution system. Environ Softw, 8(2): 101–13.
[6] Eiger, GU., Shamir, U., and Ben-Tal, A. (1994). Optimal design of water distribution networks. Water Resour Res, 30(9): 2637–46.
[7] Basha, HA., and Kassab, BG. (1996). Analysis of water distribution systems using a perturbation method. Appl Math Model, 20(4):290–7.
[8] Dandy, G. C., Simpson, A. R., and Murphy, L. J. (1996). An improved genetic algorithm for pipe network optimization. Water Resources Research 32 (2), 449-458.
[9] Savic, D.A., and Walters, G.A. (1997). Genetic algorithms for least-cost design of water distribution networks. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management-ASCE 123 (2), 67-77.
[10] Gupta, I., Gupta, A., and Khanna, P. (1999). Genetic algorithm for optimization of water distribution systems. Environmental Modelling & Software 14 (5)- 437e446.
[11] Todini, E. (2000). Looped water distribution networks design using a resilience index based heuristic approach. Urban Water, 2(2):115–22.
[12] Arsene, CTC., Bargiela, A., and Al-Dabass, D. (2004). Modelling and simulation of water systems based on loop equations. Int J Simul, 5(1-2): 61–72.
[13] Zecchin, AC., Simpson, AR., Maier, HR., Leonard, M., Roberts, AJ., and Berrisford, MJ. (2006). Application of two ant colony optimisation algorithms to water distribution system optimisation. Math Comput Model, 44(4-5):451–68.
[14] Boulos, PF., Lansey, KE., and Karney, BW. (2006). Comprehensive water distribution systems analysis handbook for engineers and planners. 2nd. MWH: Hardback. [15] Giustolisi, O. (2010). Considering actual pipe connections in water distribution network analysis. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, Vol. 136, No. 11, 889-900.
[16] Ayad, A., Awad, H., and Yassin, A. (2013). Developed hydraulic simulation model for water pipeline networks. Alexandria Eng, J., 52: 43–49. [17] Moosavian, N. and Jaefarzadeh, M. R. (2014a). Hydraulic analysis of water distribution network using shuffled complex evolution. Journal of Fluids , Vol. 2014, 1-12.
[18] Moosavian, N., and Jaefarzadeh, M. R. (2014b). Hydraulic Analysis of Water Supply Networks Using a Modified Hardy Cross Method. International Journal of Engineering, Vol. 27, No. 9, 1331-1338.
[19] Boanoa, F., Scibettab, M., Ridolfia, L., and Giustolisic, O. (2015). Water distribution system modeling and optimization: a case study. Procedia Engineering, 119, 719 – 724
[20] Creacoa, E., and Franchinib, M. (2015). The identification of loops in water distribution networks. Procedia Engineering, 119, 506 – 515.
[21] Singh, M., Kheer, S.K., and Pandita, I.K. (2016). Improvement of water distribution networks analysis by topological similarity, Alexandria Engineering Journal, 55, 1375–1383.
[22] Jha, K., and Mishra, M.K. (2018). “Modified Newton-Raphson Technique for Integrated Object-Oriented Water Pipe Network Analysis”, 1st International WDSA / CCWI , Joint Conference, Kingston, Ontario, Canada, 23-25.
[23] Wang, Y. J. (1982). Ventilation Network Theory. Mine Ventilation and Air Conditioning. 2nd ed., H. L. Hartman (Ed.), Wiley-Interscience, NY, pp. 167-195.
[24] Wang, Y. J. (1982). Critical Path Approach to Mine Ventilation Networks with Controlled Flow. Trans. SMEAIME, Vol. 272, pp. 1862-72. [25] Wang, Y. J. (1984). A Non-Linear Programming Formulation for Mine Ventilation Networks with Natural Splitting. International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Science, Vol. 21, No. 1, pp. 42-3-45.
[26] Wang, Y. J. (1989). “A Procedure for Solving A More Generalized System of Mine Ventilation Network Equations”. Proceedings of the 4th US. Mine Ventilation Symposium, SME, Littleton, Co., pp. 419-424.
[27] Bhamidipati, S. S., and Procarione, J. A. (1985). Linear Analysis for the Solution of Flow Distribution Problems. Proceedings of the 2nd US Mine Ventilation Symposium, Mousset_Jones, P. (Ed.), Rotterdam, Netherlands, pp. 645- 654.
[28] Hu, W., and Longson, I. (1990). The Optimization of Airflow Distribution in Ventilation Networks Using A Nonlinear Programming Method. Mining Science and Technology, Vol. 10, No. 2, pp. 209-219.
[29] Kamba, G. M., Jacques, E., and Patigny, J. (1995). Application of the Simplex Method to the Optimal Adjustment of the Parameters of A Ventilation Network. Proceedingss of the 7th US Mine Ventilation Symposium, Wala, A. M. (Ed.), SME, Littleton, Co., pp. 461-465.
[30] Madani, H. (2003). Mines Ventilation. Vol. 2, Tehran: Amirkabir University of Technology (Tehran Polytechnic) Press.
[31] Madani, H. (2006). Mines Ventilation. Vol. 1, Print 5, Tehran: University Center Pub.
[32] Khaled Ali El-Nagdy. (2008). Analysis of Complex Ventilation Networks in Multiple Fan Coal Mine. Ph.D thesis, West Virginia University.
[33] Brkic, D. (2009). An improvement of Hardy Cross method applied on looped spatial natural gas distribution networks. Applied Energy, Vol. 86, pp. 1290-1300.
[34] Elahi, E. and Rabienejad, H. (2012a). Designing ventilation of west Razmja coal mine of Eastern Alborz Coal Mines Company using Ventsim software. 1st Iranian coal congress , Shahrood University of Technology, pp. 1-11.
[35] Elahi, E. and Rabienejad, H. (2012b). Selection of main ventilation fan of Kalariz coal mine in Eastern Alborz Coal Mines Company using Ventsim software. 1st Iranian Mining Technologies Conference, pp. 333-343.
[36] Elahi, E. (2014). The Effect of Natural Ventilation on Coal Mine of Western Zemestan Yourt by Ventsim Software. 2nd Iranian coal congress, Shahrood University of Technology, pp. 1-7.
[37] Elahi, E. (2014). Designing Ventilation in Underground Mining by Manual Method (Case Study: Coal Mine of Takht). 5st mining engineering congress , Tehran, Iran, pp. 457-463.
[38] Elahi, E. (2014). The Principles of Designing Ventilation in Mines. Publication of Jihad Amikabir University.
[39] Elahi, E. (2014). The Improvement of Hrady Cross Method in the Analysis of Underground Excavations Ventilation Network. Tunneling and Underground Space Engineering, pp. 101-117.
[40] Elahi, E., Zeinaly, H. and Amini, E. (2016). Ventilation Design of Big Mine by Ring Method.1st engineering congress of Mining, Metals and Material, Iran, pp. 1-11.
[41] Elahi, E., Faalian, Kh. and Shakoor Shahabi. R. (2016). Selection of Main Fan for Ventilation Network of Coal Mine of Tunnel 8 using Ventsim Software. 3rd National Iranian coal congress, Shahrood University of Technology, pp. 1-7.
[42] Ghazvini, M.R. and Elahi, E. (2018). Selection of Main Fan for Ventilation Network of Coal Mine of Central Kalariz using Ventsim Software. 4th National Iranian coal congress , Shahrood University of Technology, pp. 1-8.
[43] Darvishi, M. and Barati, A. (2007). A third-order Newtontype method to solve systems of nonlinear equations. Applied Mathematics and Computation, Vol. 187, No. 2, 630-635.
[44] Li, X., Mu, C., Ma, J. and Wang, C. (2010). Sixteenth-order method for nonlinear equations, Applied Mathematics and Computation, Vol. 215, No. 10, 3754-3758.