Stability assessment of the Farrokhi earth embankment dam using the pseudo-static and deformation based methods

Document Type: Reply to comment on Paper

Authors

1 Faculty of Engineering, University of Birjand

2 Assistant professor, Faculty of Engineering, University of Birjand

Abstract

The behavior of earth dams has particular complexities against dynamic forces and its assessment requires
detailed and scientific analysis. The Farrokhi earth dam is a heterogeneous type with vertical clay core, built 150 km away from Birjand and 41 km away from Qaen on the Farrokhi River. There are concerns
regarding the stability of this dam in the event of a future severe earthquake especially because of its
placement near the active faults of eastern Iran, a very active seismic area in the country. In this study, the
pseudo-static analysis, sliding block model and Singh et al empirical relationships were adopted to evaluate safety of the Farrokhi dam against the design earthquake. Based on the findings of the present study, the
stability of the Farrokhi earth dam is not guaranteed and as such, small to large size slope failures are expected especially in the upstream side. The pseudo-static analysis and the Singh et al empirical relationships revealed similar conclusions about the stability condition of this dam, while the sliding block method underestimated the earthquake related deformations.

Keywords


[1] Sivakumar Babu, G.L., Srivastava, A. & Sahana, V. (2007). Analysis of stability of earthen dams in kachchh region, Gujarat, India.Engineering Geology, 94, 123-136.
[2] Harder, L.F.Jr. (1991). Performance of earth dams during the Loma Prieta earthquake.Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Recent Advances in Geotechnical Earthquake Engineering and Soil Dynamics, University of Missouri, Rolla.
[3] Newmark, N. (1965). Effects of earthquakes on dams and embankments.Geotechnique, 15(2), 139-160.
[4] Singh, R., Roy, D., Jain, S.K.(2005). Analysis of earth dams affected by 2001 Bhuj earthquake. Engineering geology, 80, 282–291.
[5] Rampello,S., Cascone, E. & Grosso, N. (2009). Evaluationoftheseismicresponseofahomogeneousearthdam. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 29, 782–798.
[6] Bakır, B.S. & Akıs E. (2005). Analysis of a highway embankment failure associated with the 1999 Duzce, Turkey earthquake. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering 25, 251–260.
[7] Dehvari, M.E., Noferesti, H., Azimian, A., &Mohammadi, M. (2013). Stability analysis of the slopes overlooking Birjand's Havanan village under seismic loading. World Applied Sciences Journal 22 (8), 1151-1161. doi: 10.5829/idosi.wasj.2013.22.08.477.
[8] Chakraborty, D. & Choudhury, D.(2013). Pseudo-static and pseudo-dynamic stability analysis of tailings dam under seismic conditions, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, India Section A: Physical Sciences,83(1),63-71.
[9] Delgadoa, J., Garridob, J.,Lentic, L.,Lopez-Casadod, C., Martinoe, S., &Sierra, F.J. (2015). Unconventional pseudostatic stability analysis of the Diezma landslide (Granada, Spain) based on a high-resolution engineering-geological model.Engineering Geology, 184,81–95.doi:10.1016/j.enggeo.2014.11.002.
[10] Roy, D., Dayal, U., & Jain, S.K. (2007). IITK-GSDMA guidelines for seismic design of earth dams and embankments, provisions with
commentary and explanatory examples. Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur.
[11] Srivastava, A., &SivakumarBabu, G.L. (2010). Total risk rating stability analysis of embankment dams in the Kachchh region, Gujarat, India.Engineering Geology, 115, 68-79.
[12] Kavoushpay Mashhad Company, (2009). Report of design and construction studies for The Farrokhi dam, and its irrigation network.
[13] Fallah, H. (2011).Pseudo-static stability analysis of The Farrokhi earth embankment dam.MSc Thesis, University of Birjand.
[14] Noferesti, H., Fallah, H., Golabchi, Y.& Rezaee, M. (2015). Total risk rating and liquefaction analysis of farrokhi earth embankment dam, eastern Iran.Indian Geotech J, 45(2), 181-191.doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s40098-014-0117-3.
[15] Hynes-Griffin, M.E.&Franklin, A.G. (1984). Rationalizing the seismic coefficient method. Miscellaneous Paper GL-84-13, U. S. Army Engineer Waterways Experiment Station, Vicksburg, Mississippi, 34 p.
[16] Singh, R., Roy, D., & Das, D. (2007). A correlation for permanent earthquake-induced deformation of earth embankments. Engineering Geology, 90, 174–185.
[17] Rahimi, H.(2005). Earthen dams.Tehran University.Second edition, Tehran.
[18] Fellnius,W.(1927). Stability analysis of earth slope.Van Nostrand Reinhold co, New York.
[19] Bishop, A.W. (1955). The use of slipe circle in the stability analysis of slope. Geotechnique, 5, 7-17.
[20] Janbu, N. (1973).Slope stability computation.Slope Stability Computation in Embankment Dam Engineering, New York, 1973.
[21] Spencer, E. (1967). A method of analysis of the stability of embankments assuming parallel inter-slice forces.Geotechnique, 17, 11-26.
[22] Morgenstern, N.R.,& Price, V.E. (1965).The analysis of the stability of general slip surfaces.Geotechnique, 15, 79-93.
[23] USACE.(1992). Geologic hazards evaluation, appendix F.U.S Army Corps of Engineers, Washington DC.
[24] Bowels, D.S., Anderson, L.R. & Glover, T.F.(1996). Risk assessment approach to dam safety criteria, uncertainty in geologic environment, from theory to practice.Proceedings of ASCE, STP, 58.
[25] Greco, V.R. (1996). Efficient Monte Carlo technique for locating critical slip surface.Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, 122, 517-525.
[26] Duncan, J.M. (2000) Factors of safety and reliability in geotechnical engineering.Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 126, 307-316.
[27] USACE.(1997). Risk-based analysis in geotechnical engineering for support of planning.U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Washington DC.
[28] USACE.(2003). Slope stability.U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Washington DC.
[29] Olson, S.W.,& Stark, T.D. (2003).Yield strength ratio and liquefaction analysis of slopes and embankment.Journal of Geotechnical and Geo environmental Engineering, 129, 727-737.